Gear & People

Inside Stories: Why Reviews of Expensive Cables Were TabooInside Stories Why Reviews of Expensive Cables Were Taboo

An inexpensive cable that left old references behind, until it turned out the comparison cables had aged. Why AUDIO stopped testing expensive interconnects. Until now.

Inside Stories: Why Reviews of Expensive Cables Were Taboo

The decision not to cover expensive RCA cables in the magazines I was responsible for dates back to the early 2000s. At that time I had left my beloved AUDIO magazine for a short while to contribute – and of course gain – experience at the sister title “video.” There I received a request from a typical high-end manufacturer who had evidently devised a rather clever replica of one of the expensive cables of the day and was now – no surprise – looking for a sales-boosting review. For “video” magazine this was of course out of the question, even if the cable was supposed to cost only a quarter of what the trendy original went for. In a typical home cinema application, the cabling would then have cost more than the amplifier and speakers together. I did, however, actually listen to this cable and compared it with various high-priced interconnects. I was blown away!

The new, considerably cheaper alternative outclassed the old masters almost bizarrely: especially in the upper midrange, the old heroes sounded almost a little distorted. I handed the supposed wonder cable to a colleague at AUDIO and fully expected to read a detailed review supporting my experience in one of the next issues. But what happened: nothing. The cable was okay, but nothing special really, my former colleagues told me. Reason enough for me to get to the bottom of it. In fact, I had compared the new connection with cables from my own stock, some of which had been in use for a few years. In other words: they were “old,” and this aging evidently changed their acoustic performance. When I returned to AUDIO and some time later took over as editor-in-chief, my colleagues and I tried, with the help of scientific institutions, to set up an experiment simulating this aging process. Unfortunately it didn't work, and that led me to stop testing expensive interconnects (specifically: small-signal cables) altogether. Until last week. Now I've heard one that redefines the subject. I look forward to reporting on it in the coming days.

View the post on Facebook →

From the discussion

4 comments

“A lovely, enlightening report – many thanks for it”

A voice from the discussion

The story behind the cable review ban drew a few comments. “A lovely, enlightening report,” one writes; another is curious about the announced wonder cable, and a third wants to install it if it's clearly better and affordable.

A discussion about cable aging was evidently removed by the moderators. JP leaves a note about it: the dielectric constant of copper oxide is many times higher than that of copper. Anyone accusing others, especially renowned companies, of being unscientific should please back that up in future. “Physics decides. And the moderators.”

This summary is based on the 4 comments available on Facebook when they were collected.

Show all comments (4)Hide comments

Comments from the Facebook page in the original German, names shortened.

  1. On Facebook♥ 1

    Schöner, erhellender Bericht - vielen Dank dafür

  2. On Facebook♥ 1

    Na, auf dieses Wunderkabel bin ich jetzt mal gespannt ...

  3. On Facebook

    Wenn das Kabel deutlich besser und bezahlbar ist, werde ich es verbauen

  4. JP

    Die Dielektrizitätskonstante von Kupfer liegt etwas unter 1, die von Kupferoxid bei ca.15,6. Die Diskussion hierzu haben wir aufgelöst. Wer andere Leser, erst recht solche von anerkannten Firmen, der Unwissenschaftlichkeit zeiht, sollte dies zukünftig bitte direkt belegen. Die Physik entscheidet. Und die Moderation 👀