Kettenkritik #6: Jan Pippel – System Over SceneKettenkritik #6 Jan Pippel – System Over Scene
The first reader's system in the series: a chain that wasn't put together but developed.


Now it gets concrete.
For the first time, this isn't about an abstract consideration, but about a real system that a reader has presented here. No theory, no debate of principles, but a concrete setup with comprehensible decisions. Jan Pippel didn't simply put his system together, he developed it – step by step, listening, reacting, adjusting. That's exactly what makes this case interesting.
Jan Pippel's system can be read comparatively clearly, even though I haven't heard it. The basis is his information, the photo and the measurement graph. Nothing more is needed in this case, because the essential decisions are out in the open.
First, a necessary clarification: the photo doesn't show the current speaker. What you see are older Acoustic Energy models. Jan now works with an individually derived design based on a development by Gerd Lommersum, whose crossover has been tuned to the specific room and listening position.
That automatically shifts the focus. This isn't about swapping components, but about adapting a central element of the system to real conditions.
The rest of the system is structured accordingly. Onix OA21s with external power supply, Audio-GD R2R 11 MKII as DAC and headphone amplifier, plus the analog side with a Kenwood KP-07 M, Sumiko arm, Alps phono stage and Sumiko Amethyst. Digital playback is handled pragmatically, among other things via a WiiM Pro. As for cables, a distinction is made between self-made solutions for analog and power and off-the-shelf products for digital.
This combination is coherent in itself. It follows no obvious hierarchy of brands or price classes, but a functional order.
The room is no side issue. The photo shows a bedroom with a sloping ceiling, wall-to-wall carpet and typical furniture. The speakers stand about forty centimeters (16 inches) out in the open, around 2.8 meters (9 feet) apart. The listening position is just under three meters (10 feet) away and about one meter (3 feet) in front of the rear wall.
This geometry already explains a large part of what is visible in the measurement graph.
The frequency response at the listening position shows an overall controlled curve with a clearly pronounced dip around 100 Hz. At the same time, a rise can be seen in the deep bass that corresponds to the described use of the room mode at around 35 Hz.
Both are consistent.
A listening position about one meter from the rear wall typically leads to cancellations in the range between about 80 and 120 Hz. The exact location depends on room depth, geometry and reflection behavior. The dip measured here lies exactly in this expected range.
The rise in the deep bass is also plausible. If a room mode is used deliberately, there is a corresponding increase in energy which – depending on how pronounced it is – can be perceived as an extension or as overemphasis.
That also makes it clear where the system currently stands. The basic structure is coherent; the remaining deviation lies not in the electronics but in the interplay of speaker, listening position and room.
Against this background, the question of “improvement” automatically shifts.
Replacing the amplifier, DAC or cartridge would hardly change anything about the problem described. The relevant starting point is the geometry. Concretely, that means: varying the listening position along the room axis, ideally in small, traceable steps. Even shifts of just a few centimeters can bring about significant changes in this frequency range.
In parallel, the position of the speakers should be considered. Distance from the front wall, lateral position and toe-in influence the ratio of direct sound to reflections and thus also how pronounced dips and peaks are.
A second level concerns signal processing. If Roon is used, it provides tools that allow a targeted, moderate correction. The direction is crucial: the dip at 100 Hz should not be boosted. It makes more sense to reduce peaks – for example in the range of the room mode being used – if they are perceived as dominant in everyday listening. Adjustments on the order of one to two decibels are more realistic here than larger corrections.
Beyond that, adding subwoofers would be a technically clean option. Not in the sense of raising the level, but to excite the room more evenly. Several freely positioned sources can distribute modes differently than a single speaker system. The prerequisite, however, is precise matching of level, phase and crossover frequency.
The analog side plays a subordinate role in this context. Changes to the tonearm or cartridge influence detail resolution and tonal nuances, but don't touch the fundamental room problem.
That's exactly where the strength of this system lies. The essential parameters are known, the deviations explainable, the possible next steps clearly definable.
That's not a spectacular finding, but a solid one. And that is exactly where the value of this example lies.
For this series, it's a useful reference point. Not as a template in the sense of “this is how you should do it,” but as an example of how a system develops from comprehensible decisions – and where the limits of such decisions lie.
And that is also the invitation: anyone who presents their own system here ideally provides not just a list of components, but a system. With connections, with decisions, with an “idea.” That's exactly what makes this series exciting – and that's exactly how it continues now.